3 Comments
User's avatar
Polly Young-Eisendrath, PhD's avatar

Oops: it was Truman and not Eisenhower who gave the go-ahead for the bomb to be dropped on Hiroshima…that’s a great example of how faulty my memory can be. Apologies; I don’t want to start a narrative about Eisenhower on this!

Expand full comment
Polly Young-Eisendrath, PhD's avatar

Hi Richard: many of the leaders were/are well-intentioned and well-educated, just like you and me. I have not read all of their biographies, but I know a bit about Churchill and Roosevelt and a few others. I believe their intentions were to “win” because they believed in “our side,” and they I believe they thought of the “enemy” (German, Japanese) sub- human. How could Eisenhower (who did some good things and was well educated) agree to drop a bomb on two Japanese cities in which hundreds of thousands of mostly civilians were instantly or gradually killed? How can you or I humanize our views of others, giving them the benefit of the doubt about their humanity? Using the skill of Real Dialogue: speak for yourself and listen mindfully. Don’t speak of the “others” unless you have direct experience and then speak modestly. Thanks for your comments.

Expand full comment
Richard Hill's avatar

“Reflect for a minute on the massive exterminations and annihilations of other human beings in the 20th and 21st centuries alone: civilized societies led by well-educated and well-intentioned leaders…”

In my opinion the vast majority of the events referred to( whatever they are!) we’re not led by well educated or well intentioned leaders.

Expand full comment